Understanding the Constitutional Convention and the Scope of Pardoning Power Under Article 72
The constitutional convention and the scope of pardoning power under Article 72 refer to the historical practices, judicial precedents, and legal limits governing the President of India’s authority to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, or remissions of punishment. This topic is vital for government exams like UPSC and State PCS because it tests a candidate’s understanding of executive powers, the separation of powers, and the system of checks and balances in Indian polity.
Constitutional Background and Origins of Article 72
The Constituent Assembly debated the executive power of clemency extensively before adopting Article 72 into the Constitution of India in 1950. The framers drew inspiration from the Government of India Act of 1935 and the British Crown’s prerogative of mercy.
Key Debates in the Constituent Assembly
- Dr. B.R. Ambedkar and other members argued that an executive head must possess the power to correct judicial errors or provide humanitarian relief.
- The assembly recognized that absolute human infallibility does not exist in judicial systems, making a final mercy appeal necessary.
- Framers decided to vest this authority in the President of India at the central level and the Governors under Article 161 at the state level.
Scope and Types of Pardoning Powers
Article 72 empowers the President of India to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, and remissions to persons convicted of offenses in specific scenarios.
Five Distinct Forms of Clemency
- Pardon: Completely absolves the convict of all offenses, punishments, and disqualifications, restoring them to the exact legal status of an innocent person.
- Commutation: Substitutes one form of punishment with a lighter form, such as converting a death sentence into rigorous imprisonment.
- Remission: Reduces the quantum of the sentence without changing its character, such as reducing rigorous imprisonment from ten years to five years.
- Respite: Awards a lesser sentence instead of the prescribed punishment due to special circumstances, such as the physical disability of a convict or pregnancy of a woman offender.
- Reprieve: Stays the execution of a sentence, particularly a death sentence, for a temporary period to allow the convict time to seek pardon or commutation.
Judicial Review and Limitations on Article 72
While the executive power under Article 72 appears absolute on paper, the Supreme Court of India has established clear parameters to prevent arbitrary decisions.
Landmark Judgments and Principles
- The Supreme Court ruled in the Epuru Sudhakar case that the presidential pardon is subject to judicial review on limited grounds.
- Judicial review applies if the order is found to be arbitrary, irrational, mala fide, discriminatory, or based on irrelevant considerations.
- The President acts on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister in all matters under Article 72, as established in the Maru Ram case.
Comparison of Pardoning Powers Under Article 72 and Article 161
Candidates preparing for competitive examinations must understand the clear jurisdictional differences between the executive clemency powers of the President and the Governor.
| Feature | President (Article 72) | Governor (Article 161) |
|---|---|---|
| Court Martial | Can pardon, reprieve, or commute sentences inflicted by court martial. | Has no power to deal with court martial or military court sentences. |
| Death Sentence | Can grant a pardon or commutation for any death sentence across India. | Cannot pardon a death sentence, though powers of suspension or remission apply. |
| Jurisdiction | Extends to all cases where punishment is by a Union law. | Extends only to cases where punishment is by a state law. |
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the primary objective of Article 72 in the Indian Constitution?
Article 72 empowers the President of India to grant pardons and reduce sentences, serving as a constitutional safeguard against judicial errors and offering humanitarian relief to deserving convicts. - Can the President of India pardon a death sentence?
Yes, the President has the exclusive power under Article 72 to grant a complete pardon, commute, remit, respite, or reprieve in cases involving a death sentence. - Is the President bound by the advice of the cabinet while deciding mercy petitions?
Yes, the President acts on the aid and advice of the Union Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister when exercising pardoning powers under Article 72. - Are decisions made under Article 72 subject to judicial review?
Yes, the Supreme Court ruled that presidential pardons are subject to judicial review if the decision is arbitrary, irrational, malafide, or taken without considering relevant material facts. - What is the difference between remission and commutation?
Commutation changes the character of the punishment to a lighter form, whereas remission reduces the quantum or duration of the sentence without changing its original character. - Can a Governor pardon a sentence awarded by a military court?
No, a Governor does not possess the authority to pardon, commute, or remit sentences given by a court martial or military court. - Which constitutional article deals with the pardoning power of the Governor?
Article 161 of the Indian Constitution grants the Governor of a state the power to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, and remissions in respect of state laws.
Stay Updated with Daily Current Affairs 2026
Discover more from Current Affairs World
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
