The global economy’s rapid digitalization has presented a profound challenge to traditional international tax norms, which were designed for a physical presence-based business model. Digital services providers often generate significant revenue in a country without establishing a physical footprint, leading to a disconnect between where value is created and where profits are taxed. This lacuna has prompted countries worldwide, including India, to explore and implement unilateral measures like the Digital Services Tax (DST) or Equalisation Levy, while simultaneously engaging in multilateral efforts to forge a new, equitable global tax framework. India’s proactive stance in this evolving landscape is crucial for understanding the future of international taxation.
Understanding the Digital Services Tax (DST)
The Digital Services Tax (DST) is a levy imposed on the revenues of large technology companies that provide digital services, rather than on their profits. It is typically applied to specific services like digital advertising, social media platforms, search engines, and data monetization, where user participation and data are key value drivers. The core objective of DSTs is to address the perceived unfairness where highly profitable digital companies pay little to no tax in jurisdictions where they generate substantial sales and user engagement.
• Traditional tax rules, based on physical presence, struggled to tax the profits of digital companies operating remotely.
• DSTs emerged as an interim solution by various countries to assert taxing rights over revenue generated from their digital markets.
• Unlike corporate income tax, DST is often applied as a low-rate tax on gross revenues, making it easier to administer for activities that lack a physical nexus.
India’s Equalisation Levy: A Pioneering Approach
India has been at the forefront of taxing the digital economy, introducing its Equalisation Levy (EL) well before many other nations. Initially implemented in 2016, and subsequently expanded, the EL targets non-resident e-commerce operators and digital service providers, aiming to level the playing field between online and offline businesses and ensure fair contribution from profits derived from Indian users.
• Equalisation Levy 2016: Introduced a 6% levy on payments made to non-resident entities for specific digital advertising services and related services, where the aggregate consideration exceeds a specified threshold in a financial year.
• Equalisation Levy 2020: Expanded the scope to a 2% levy on the consideration received or receivable by an e-commerce operator from e-commerce supply or services made or provided to residents in India, or to non-residents in specified circumstances, covering online sale of goods and provision of services.
• The EL is applicable if the e-commerce operator has a gross turnover exceeding INR 2 crores (approximately USD 270,000) during the previous year.
• India’s ‘Significant Economic Presence’ (SEP) concept under its income tax law also sought to expand the tax nexus for digital businesses, complementing the EL’s objectives.
Global Tax Norms: The OECD/G20 Inclusive Framework on BEPS
Recognizing the fragmentation caused by unilateral DSTs and the broader challenges of base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS), the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and G20, through their Inclusive Framework, have been working towards a comprehensive multilateral solution. This effort culminated in a two-pillar solution designed to reallocate taxing rights and establish a global minimum corporate tax.
• Pillar One – Reallocation of Profit: Aims to reallocate a portion of the profits of the largest and most profitable multinational enterprises (MNEs) from their home countries to market jurisdictions where they have sales and user engagement, irrespective of physical presence. This includes ‘Amount A’ (reallocation of residual profit) and ‘Amount B’ (simplification of arm’s length principle for baseline marketing and distribution activities).
• Pillar Two – Global Minimum Tax: Establishes a global minimum corporate tax rate of 15% on MNEs’ profits. It comprises the Income Inclusion Rule (IIR) and the Undertaxed Profits Rule (UTPR), designed to ensure that MNEs pay a minimum level of tax on profits earned in each jurisdiction in which they operate, discouraging profit shifting to low-tax jurisdictions.
• The Inclusive Framework seeks to create a stable and fairer international tax system, urging countries to withdraw unilateral DSTs upon the successful implementation of Pillar One.
India’s Position and Challenges in the Evolving Landscape
India has actively participated in the OECD/G20 Inclusive Framework negotiations, advocating for the interests of developing countries and ensuring a fair share of taxing rights over the digital economy. India’s position is complex, balancing its support for a multilateral solution with its right to tax digital revenues generated within its borders through mechanisms like the Equalisation Levy.
• India supports a global consensus but insists that any new framework must result in a substantial and equitable reallocation of taxing rights to market jurisdictions, especially for developing economies.
• India has maintained that its Equalisation Levy would be withdrawn only upon the successful and robust implementation of Pillar One, ensuring that the revenue gains from Pillar One at least match or exceed those from the EL.
• Challenges include navigating potential trade retaliations (such as the US Section 301 investigation against DSTs) and ensuring that the final global agreement adequately addresses the unique characteristics and complexities of the Indian digital market.
• The successful integration of India’s existing domestic tax measures with the future global framework will be critical for avoiding double taxation and ensuring compliance for multinational businesses operating in India.
Implications for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administration
The evolving global tax norms, including DSTs and the OECD’s two-pillar solution, have significant implications for multinational enterprises (MNEs) and national tax administrations. MNEs face increased complexity, compliance burdens, and the potential for higher tax liabilities, while tax authorities must adapt their frameworks and enforcement mechanisms.
• MNEs, particularly those in the technology sector, must reassess their global tax strategies, transfer pricing policies, and compliance mechanisms to navigate the new rules.
• Increased transparency requirements and enhanced international cooperation among tax authorities aim to reduce opportunities for aggressive tax planning and profit shifting.
• National tax administrations, including India’s, need to invest in capacity building, data analytics, and digital tools to effectively implement and enforce the complex new global tax rules.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
- What is the Digital Services Tax (DST)?
The DST is a tax on the revenue generated by large digital companies from services like online advertising and e-commerce. It addresses how to tax profits made by companies with significant user bases but without traditional physical presence in a country.
- What is India’s Equalisation Levy?
India’s Equalisation Levy (EL) is a form of DST. Introduced in 2016 (6% on digital advertising) and expanded in 2020 (2% on e-commerce operators), it taxes revenues of non-resident digital businesses providing services to Indian users.
- What are OECD’s Pillar One and Pillar Two proposals?
Pillar One reallocates taxing rights of large MNEs to market jurisdictions. Pillar Two establishes a global minimum corporate tax rate of 15% to prevent profit shifting and ensure MNEs pay a fair share of tax worldwide.
- Why is India’s stance on DST significant?
India’s stance is significant because it has been a pioneer in implementing a unilateral DST (Equalisation Levy) and actively advocates for developing countries’ interests in global tax reforms, seeking equitable allocation of taxing rights from digital giants.
Stay Updated with Daily Current Affairs 2026
Discover more from Current Affairs World
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
